If you need a replacement key for your vehicle, you might wonder what the best option is. There are two main processes that locksmiths use to create new keys: key cloning and key cutting. Key cloning and key cutting are two methods that locksmiths use to create duplicate or replacement keys for vehicles. Both processes involve using specialized tools and equipment to produce a new key. One can start the ignition and unlock the doors of your car. The main difference between key cloning and key cutting is that key cloning uses the transponder data from the original key, while key cutting creates a new key from scratch. A transponder is a small chip embedded in the head of the key that communicates with the vehicle’s computer system.
The transponder data contains a unique code that identifies the key and allows it to start the engine. Key cloning copies this code and transfers it to a new key. While key cutting creates a new code and programs it to the vehicle. In this article, we will explain what these processes are, how they differ, and what are their advantages and disadvantages. We will also provide some tips on how to choose the best service for your needs and how to keep your keys and vehicle safe. Let’s dive into this article and know the difference between key cloning and key cutting.
Key Cloning
Key cloning is a process that involves copying the transponder data from the original key and transferring it to a new key. This way, the new key becomes a replica of the original key and can start the vehicle without any reprogramming. Key cloning requires the original key to be present and functional, as well as a key cloning machine, a blank key, and a transponder chip.
Steps to Follow:
Step 1: Insert the original key into the key cloning machine and scans the transponder data.
Step 2: Insert the blank key into the key cloning machine and copies the transponder data onto the new key.
Step 3: Cut the new key to match the shape and grooves of the original key using a key cutting machine.
Step 4: Necessarily test the new key in the vehicle to ensure that it works properly.
Pros:
- Cheaper than key cutting, as it does not require reprogramming the vehicle or buying a new lock.
- Simpler than key cutting, as it does not involve creating a new code or modifying the vehicle’s computer system.
- Faster than key cutting, as it takes less time and effort to complete.
- More convenient than key cutting, as it can be done on the spot and does not require the vehicle to be towed.
Cons:
- It is not an option for lost or stolen keys, as it requires the original key to be present and functional.
- Key cutting is more secure than this method, which creates a duplicate key that anyone can use.
- Key cutting is more versatile than this method, which only works for certain types of keys and vehicles.
Preferable:
- As a backup service, in case the original key is damaged or malfunctioning.
- For spare keys, in case the customer wants to have an extra key for convenience or emergency.
- Older vehicles, that have simple transponder systems that are easy to clone.
- For customers who are on a tight budget or in a hurry and do not want to spend more money or time on key cutting.
Key Cutting
Key cutting is a process that involves creating a new key from scratch without using the transponder data from the original key. In this process, we model and shape a new key to match the lock and the ignition of the vehicle, as well as program a new code into the vehicle’s computer system. We can cut the key to match an existing key or the lock itself. Key cutting requires a key cutting machine, a blank key, a transponder chip, and a diagnostic tool. The key cutting process is more complicated and time-consuming than key cloning. The duration of this task is normally in the range of half an hour to 60 minutes.
Steps to Follow
Step 1: One should Insert the existing key or the lock into the key cutting machine and scans the shape and grooves of the key or the lock.
Step 2: Insert the blank key into the key cutting machine and cuts the new key to match the shape and grooves of the existing key or the lock.
Step 3: Try to Insert the transponder chip into the new key and programs a new code using a diagnostic tool and the vehicle’s computer system.
Step 4: One should test the new key in the vehicle to ensure that it works properly.
Pros:
- More versatile than key cloning, as it can be done for any type of key and vehicle, regardless of the transponder system.
- More secure than key cloning, as it creates a new key that has a unique code that only the vehicle’s computer system can recognize.
- More reliable than key cloning, as it eliminates the risk of copying errors or defects.
Cons:
- Expensive than key cloning, as it requires reprogramming the vehicle and buying a new lock or a new transponder chip.
- Complicated than key cloning, as it involves creating a new code and modifying the vehicle’s computer system.
- More time-consuming than key cloning, as it takes more time and effort to complete.
- Less convenient than key cloning, as it might require the vehicle to be towed or the lock to be removed.
Preferable:
- As an emergency service, in case the original key is lost or stolen, and the customer needs a new key as soon as possible.
- For lost or stolen keys, in case the customer wants to prevent unauthorized access to the vehicle.
- If the customer wishes to replace the vehicle’s lock or ignition for any reason, one can install new locks.
- Key cutting is best option for newer vehicles, that have more advanced and complex transponder systems that are difficult or impossible to clone.
Comparison and Contrast
Key cloning and key cutting are two different processes that locksmiths use to create new keys for vehicles. They have some similarities and differences that affect their cost, versatility, security, and other factors.
| Key Cloning | Key Cutting |
| A process that uses the data from the transponder of an existing key to create a new key that replicates the original. | A process that creates a new key from scratch without using transponder data, but by modeling the key based on the lock or an existing key. |
| A simpler and less expensive process than key cutting, since it does not require specialized tools or machines. | A more complicated and costly process than key cloning, since it requires more time, labor, and equipment. |
| A convenient and quick option for key replacement or duplication, but it requires the original key to be available. | A versatile and secure option for key replacement or creation, but it does not require the original key to be available. |
| If the original key is lost or stolen, the new key is a less secure option. Since it is identical to the original and the vehicle’s computer cannot distinguish between them. | If the original key is lost or stolen, the new key is a more secure option. You can reprogram it to work with the vehicle’s computer system. |
Similarities:
- They both involve using specialized tools and equipment to produce a new key.
- Both require the locksmith to test the new key in the vehicle to ensure that it works properly.
- They both require a blank key and a transponder chip to create a new key that has a physical and an electronic component.
Difference:
- Key cloning uses the transponder data from the original key, while key cutting creates a new key from scratch.
- This process requires the original key to be present and functional. While key cutting can be done without the original key.
- It is simpler, faster, and more convenient than key cutting. But it is also less secure, less versatile, and less reliable.
The pros and cons of each process depend on the circumstances and needs of the customer. Some customers might prefer key cloning because it is more affordable and convenient. While others might prefer key cutting because it is more secure and versatile. There is no definitive answer to which process is better, as it depends on various factors. These factors are such as the type of key and vehicle, the availability of the original key and the preference and expertise of the locksmith.
Recommendation:
- Key cloning is a suitable option for those who possess the original key and need a spare or a backup one.
- Key cutting is a preferable option for those who lack the original key or require a new lock or a replacement key.
- If one has an older vehicle that has a simple transponder system, key cloning might be easier and faster for you.
- Key cutting is a secure and reliable option for those who drive a newer vehicle with a complex transponder system.
- If you are on a tight budget or in a hurry, key cloning might be more economical and convenient for you.
- You can enjoy the benefits of key cutting if you don’t mind investing more time or money.
Video Guidance:
Here is a video guidance for you to make a difference between key cloning and key cutting:
Conclusion
In this article, we have explained the difference between key cloning and key cutting, two processes that locksmiths use to create new keys. We have described each process in detail, discussed their pros and cons and where they are suitable or preferable. Compared and contrasted key cloning and key cutting in terms of cost, versatility, security, and other factors. We also address some common questions and concerns that customers might have about these processes and offer some recommendations. If you need a new key for your vehicle, whether it is a duplicate, a replacement, or a new lock.
You should contact a professional and trustworthy locksmith who can provide key cloning or key cutting services. One such locksmith is Patriot Locksmith, a company that has been serving customers for over 20 years. Patriot locksmith has the skills and equipment to perform key cloning and key cutting for any type of key. Their team is expert in other locksmith services such as lock installation, repair, and rekeying. Patriot locksmith offers fast, reliable, and affordable services, as well as free estimates and consultations.